If a conversation left you confused about what actually happened – who said what, whether your reaction was reasonable, whether you’re remembering it accurately – writing it down soon afterward can help in a way that simply thinking about it often can’t. Here’s a specific practice, not just a general suggestion to “journal about it.”
Why writing helps more than replaying it in your head
When you replay a confusing conversation mentally, your memory of it can shift each time, especially if you’re also fielding a different version of events from someone else. Writing it down soon after it happens creates a fixed record – your own account, in your own words, from close to the actual moment – that later confusion or contradiction can’t quietly edit.
This matters more than it might sound like at first. Many survivors describe a specific kind of disorientation: being certain of what happened in the moment, then gradually feeling less certain as time passes and the other person’s version gets repeated. A written record, made close to the event, is something you can return to later as evidence of what you actually noticed – not proof for anyone else, but a fixed point for your own clarity.
The practice: three questions, right after
As soon as you reasonably can after a confusing or unsettling conversation, write brief answers to three questions. Keep it short – a few sentences per question is enough. This isn’t meant to be a polished account, just a fast, honest record.
What actually happened? Stick to facts you could describe to a neutral person: what was said, in what order, as close to verbatim as you can remember. Not your interpretation yet – just the sequence of events.
How did I feel, in the moment and right after? Name the feeling as specifically as you can – confused, dismissed, anxious, relieved, something else. You don’t need to justify the feeling here, just record it honestly.
What do I actually know to be true, regardless of how the conversation ended? This is the piece that matters most for the disorientation gaslighting can cause. Write down the one or two things you’re confident about, even if the conversation itself left everything else feeling murky.
Why the order matters
Facts first, then feelings, then your own grounded knowledge – in that order – because starting with feelings alone can pull you straight into self-doubt before you’ve anchored the actual sequence of events. Starting with the facts gives your feelings and your certainty something solid to stand on, rather than floating free and becoming easy to argue away.
I’d also suggest dating each entry and keeping these together somewhere private and secure – not to build a legal case necessarily, though it could matter later if one is ever needed, but so you can look back over several entries and notice a pattern more clearly than any single conversation reveals on its own.
What to do if you can’t write it down immediately
Sometimes you won’t have the chance to write right after a conversation – you’re at work, you’re driving, the moment isn’t private. In that case, a short voice memo to yourself, or even three words typed into your phone as a placeholder, can anchor the moment until you have time to write the fuller version later that day. The goal is capturing something close to real-time, even if it’s imperfect, rather than waiting until the memory has already started to soften or shift.
A caution about rereading too often
This practice is meant to create clarity, not to become a loop of its own. If you find yourself rereading old entries obsessively, searching for reassurance rather than clarity, that’s worth noticing too. The goal is a record you can return to when you need it – not a constant checking behavior that keeps you anxious. If journaling starts to feel compulsive rather than clarifying, that’s worth mentioning to a therapist, not something to push through alone.
Why this is worth the effort
A single written record won’t resolve a confusing relationship on its own. But a collection of honest, dated accounts – written close to the actual moments, before any later conversation had a chance to reshape your memory of them – can become one of the most useful tools you have for trusting your own perceptions again. Not because anyone else needs to see it, but because you do.
Starting today, if this is new to you
If you want to start this practice, you don’t need a special notebook or a perfect system. A phone notes app, a plain notebook, or a password-protected document all work. What matters is doing it soon after a confusing moment, answering the same three questions consistently, and keeping entries dated so you can look back later and see the actual pattern, not just a single hard conversation in isolation.
Buy Paperback on Amazon
Buy Signed Copy • PayPal